← All posts

Paid observership for IMGs in the USA: is it worth it, and 6 checks to run before you pay

Omar Saad, MBBCh· 9 min read

A paid observership is worth it, in my view, when the fee matches the standard in the AMA's "Guidelines for establishing an observership for international medical graduates": "Actual costs (administrative fees, immunizations, etc.) may be itemized and paid for by the observer." The same AMA page says "Observership programs are not intended to be organized for profit."

On price, you have two published reference points:

  • A hospital-run program. Trinity Health Mid-Atlantic's Mercy Catholic Medical Center (MCMC) Clinical Observership Program lists its fee on its "Eligibility and Application Process" page: "Four weeks: $1,500. Two weeks: $750."
  • The wider range. The American Association of Physicians of Indian Origin (AAPI) wrote in its 2020 "Clinical Observership Guidelines": "Some programs cost $1000 to observers while others charge $5,000 per month."

So in my view, a fee alone is not a warning sign. The AMA itself wrote in a 2018 news article that "IMGs pay tuition and fees for observership programs." What matters is what the fee buys, and you can find that out before you pay.

I'm an IMG myself, and I cold-emailed US physicians before building IMG Outreach. Below are the six checks I would run, in order, then a decision list and an email you can copy.

Why you have to check for yourself

Two sources say there is no outside body checking these programs:

  • AAPI: "Currently, clinical observerships remain completely unregulated."
  • The AMA, about its own guidelines: "The AMA is not an oversight or accreditation entity. These guidelines are for informational purposes only."

The AMA guidelines are a template for people setting up a program, not a rule a program must follow. So my advice is to check an offer yourself, and to use the AMA guidelines as a named standard to compare it against.

The 6 checks to run before you pay

1. Who runs it?

AAPI lists who offers observerships: "academic centers, community hospitals, private practices, and medical associations all offer observerships. There are also several for-profit broker services."

My advice: find out which one you are dealing with first.

  • Is the program run by the hospital or practice where you will observe?
  • Or is it arranged by a service that places you with a physician somewhere else?

If it is a placement service, I would ask for the name of the hospital or practice in writing. The next four checks all depend on it.

2. What does the fee cover, and is it itemized?

The AMA's wording is that actual costs "may be itemized and paid for by the observer," and its examples are "administrative fees, immunizations, etc."

So ask for the breakdown. I would want to see:

  • The total, and what each part pays for.
  • What is not included.
  • How the total compares with the two reference points above: MCMC's published $1,500 for four weeks, and AAPI's range of "$1000" to "$5,000 per month."

AAPI also says "The range of advertised experiences and costs are highly variable." A higher price is not proof of a problem. A price nobody will break down is, for me, a reason to stop and ask more.

3. Has the hospital or department approved it?

The AMA guidelines say: "Permission from the hospital and/or department chair of the physician should be obtained before beginning the observership program."

In the AMA's template, a physician's yes is not enough on its own. I would ask one plain question: has the hospital or the department chair given permission for observers, and who there can confirm it?

4. Who is the preceptor?

The AMA guidelines define the preceptor as "A licensed, preferably board-certified physician who volunteers to be a preceptor for an agreed upon period of time."

That gives you three things to ask:

  • The physician's full name and specialty.
  • Whether they are licensed and board-certified.
  • The agreed dates.

Note the word "volunteers." The same guidelines say "Physicians in each specialty should volunteer their time and efforts." I would ask whether any part of the fee is paid to the physician.

5. What may you do, and what may you not do?

AAPI's definition of an observership-only experience is that a participant "shall not have access to hands-on patient care or contact, examination, research or other work".

Hold the offer against that sentence. If a program you are paying for describes more than observing, I would ask it to say in writing what you will be allowed to do and who approved it. If you are not sure which type of experience you are being sold, read observership vs externship vs elective first.

What the program will ask from you

The AMA guidelines packet lists "Submission of USMLE transcript, Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates (ECFMG) Status Report or ECFMG Certificate." MCMC's published list includes:

  • ECFMG certification (active or inactive) and passing USMLE scores.
  • Graduation within five years preferred.
  • A valid U.S. visa, permanent residence or citizenship.
  • Vaccination status and titers, plus evacuation, repatriation and medical insurance.
  • A medical school transcript, USMLE score report, CV, one letter of recommendation, a 200-word personal statement and your ECFMG certificate.

I would ask any program for its list.

6. What happens after acceptance?

Ask about three things: when you pay, how long you stay, and what you leave with.

When you pay. MCMC's page says: "You will receive instructions on how to submit your fee after you have been accepted in the program. We can accept only cash or check." It also says "Acceptance and interview is not guaranteed." In that program, the decision comes first and the fee comes second. I would ask any program which order it uses.

How long you stay. The AMA guidelines say "Programs typically last from two to four weeks per rotation or specialty. Observers can rotate among several specialties to create a longer experience." The AMA's 2018 article says "Many programs are four weeks in length, with others going for six, 12 or as long as 48 weeks." AAPI says the length "varies from a few days to several months." Get your exact dates in writing.

What you leave with. The AMA's 2018 article says: "Depending on the observership program you choose, a good performance can lead to: A powerful letter of recommendation."

"Depending on" and "can lead to" are not a promise. I would ask whether the preceptor writes letters for observers and what that depends on. For why this matters, see US residency letters of recommendation.

Pay, ask more, or walk away

This list is my advice, not a rule from any source.

I would pay when:

  • I know who runs it and where I will observe.
  • The fee is itemized, as the AMA guideline describes.
  • The hospital or department chair has given permission.
  • I have the preceptor's name and the agreed dates.
  • What I may and may not do is written down.

I would ask more when:

  • I have a total but no breakdown.
  • The site or the physician is "to be confirmed."
  • The offer mentions a letter but not what it depends on.

I would walk away when:

  • Nobody will name the hospital, practice or preceptor before I pay.
  • Nobody will say whether the hospital or department has given permission.
  • A letter, an interview or a match is promised in exchange for the fee.

An email to send before you pay

This is my suggested wording, built from the sources above. Change the details and send it to the program contact.

``` Subject: Questions before I pay the observership fee

Dear [Name],

Thank you for the information about the [specialty] observership. Before I pay, could you confirm the following?

1. Who runs the program, and at which hospital or practice will I observe? 2. Could you send an itemized breakdown of the fee, showing what each part covers and what is not included? 3. Has the hospital or the department chair given permission for observers? Who there can confirm it? 4. Who is the preceptor? Are they licensed and board-certified? 5. What are the exact start and end dates? 6. What will I be allowed to do, and what am I not allowed to do? 7. Which documents do you need from me (for example USMLE transcript, ECFMG certificate, vaccination records, insurance)? 8. When is the fee due: before or after acceptance? Who receives it, and which payment methods do you accept? 9. Do preceptors write letters of recommendation for observers, and what does that depend on?

Thank you for your time.

Sincerely, [Your name] [Medical school, graduation year] ```

The unpaid alternative: ask physicians directly

The AMA guidelines describe a preceptor as a physician who "volunteers." So the other route is to ask a physician yourself, with no program in between.

In my experience it takes many emails, and each one has to be written for one person: their specialty, their work, your reason for asking them. A physician may like your email and still need the permission the AMA guidelines describe. The structure I use is in how to email a doctor for an observership.

That writing is what IMG Outreach helps with. It researches each US physician and drafts a personalized email. You review every draft and send it from your own Gmail. You can start with 25 free drafts.

Frequently asked questions

Is a paid observership worth it for an IMG?

In my view, yes when the fee matches what the AMA guidelines describe: "Actual costs (administrative fees, immunizations, etc.) may be itemized and paid for by the observer." Run the six checks above before you pay.

How much does a paid observership cost in the USA?

AAPI's 2020 guidelines say "Some programs cost $1000 to observers while others charge $5,000 per month." One hospital-run program, MCMC at Trinity Health Mid-Atlantic, publishes $1,500 for four weeks and $750 for two weeks.

Does a paid observership guarantee a letter of recommendation?

No source here says so. The AMA's 2018 article says a good performance "can lead to" a powerful letter, "Depending on the observership program you choose." Ask the program before you pay.

How long does an observership last?

The AMA guidelines say programs "typically last from two to four weeks per rotation or specialty." The AMA's 2018 article mentions programs of six, 12 or as long as 48 weeks.

Who regulates observership programs?

AAPI says "clinical observerships remain completely unregulated," and the AMA says it "is not an oversight or accreditation entity." That is why I would run the checks above myself.

Can I do hands-on work in a paid observership?

AAPI defines an observership-only participant as one who "shall not have access to hands-on patient care or contact, examination, research or other work". Ask the program to state in writing what you may do.